Jennifer Love Hewitt: 2002 – 2003
Almost immediately after parting ways with Carlton, John Mayer was head over hills for the Ghost Whisperer actress Jennifer Love Hewitt. However, their relationship seemed to have fizzled out before anyone even knew they were dating. The reason for their breakup is unclear.
Source: Pinterest
When the two were still together in 2002, Mayer released his second single Your Body Is a Wonderland, which is believed to have been written about Hewitt. The actress responded to the rumors in an interview with Entertainment Weekly: “My body is far from a wonderland. My body is like a pawn shop.”